L.A. Controller Releases Scathing Audit of Housing Authority

City Council calls for taking over authority of local federal agency.

By Richie Duchon, City News Service

City Controller Wendy Greuel released a sharply critical audit on Tuesday of the city’s low-income housing authority and its “reckless” spending of taxpayer money.

Lea esta nota en ESPAÑOL: Auditoria Cáustica de la Autoridad de Viviendas es Liberada por la Controladora de L.A.

The audit of the Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles found deep flaws in the agency’s travel policies, Greuel said. Commissioners and other staff used agency money to pay for the travel of non-staff members and repeatedly spent far above allowed amounts on meals without documenting what was consumed and who was present at the lunches, the audit found.

Greuel, an announced candidate for mayor, said former Housing Authority CEO Rudolf Montiel, who was fired in March, was directly to blame for the abuses. However, she said Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa also shares responsibility since he appointed the commissioners who oversee the agency.

“The mayor’s office appoints the commissioners and has oversight over those commissioners, and clearly they needed to be minding the store better,” Greuel said. “This was an agency that felt no one was watching.”

Villaraigosa’s press secretary, Peter Sanders, declined to address claims the mayor should have monitored commissioners’ lax travel policies before Greuel began auditing the agency but noted that Villaraigosa took immediate action when the matter came to his attention last spring.

“To restore trust in the agency, the mayor has appointed a majority of new commissioners, including a reform-minded chairman,” Sanders said.

“We welcome greater city oversight of HACLA and will work with City Council in addition to state and federal officials on how to best accomplish that,” Sanders added.

Villaraigosa, who is on a 10-day trade mission to Asia, also recommended that the commission name Los Angeles Housing Department General Manager Douglas Guthrie as interim chief executive officer of the agency. The board unanimously approved the recommendation on Tuesday afternoon.

The Housing Authority oversees and places residents in about 75,000 federally subsidized affordable housing units and the city’s federally funded Section 8 housing program. The Los Angeles Housing Department is funded by the city’s budget and is focused on housing code enforcement, renter and landlord complaints, and the city’s rent stabilization program.

According to Greuel’s report, employees were found to have “double-dipped,” paying for expenses with agency purchase cards and later being reimbursed for those same costs.

In one case, a public safety official at the agency was approved to drive to a conference in San Diego. Instead, the official used Housing Authority funds to pay for airfare without prior approval. Butler also left the conference early to fly to Chicago, charging the Housing Authority for a hotel night that was not used.

In another incident, former HACLA Board Member Maria Del Angel paid costs for other travelers who were not HACLA staff and for whom executive approvals were not provided, Greuel said. Del Angel served as the representative of public housing tenants, and lived at Estrada Courts prior to her current residence at the Pico Gardens public housing complex.

In total, Greuel found the agency spent about $300,000 per year on travel during 2009 and 2010, a 300 percent increase over travel expenses in 2006.

Councilman Dennis Zine, who is running for city controller, said the audit showed that illegal actions may have taken place and that some agency employees should be singled out for investigation and terminated.

The District Attorney’s Office has launched an investigation of the situation.

Greuel began her audit a few months after KCET-TV Channel 28’s “SoCal Connected” and CBS2/KCAL9 reported last March on the large travel expenses.

Greuel called the audit alarming, saying that it was “the tip of the iceberg.”

A seven-month follow-up investigation by KCET, which aired two weeks ago, found that HousingAuthority employees also spent thousands of dollars on posh lunches, work meetings and incentives such as clothes and electronics. The Los Angeles Times also reported that the housing commission approved a $1.2 million severance and settlement package for Montiel, who had alleged he was fired by former commissioners for blowing the whistle on their illegal spending, and ordering them to pay back those funds.

Commissioners said at the time that they fired Montiel because they had lost confidence in his ability to lead the agency, following reports he tried to evict tenants who led a protest in front of his home.
The reports spurred Greuel this week to announce plans for an expanded top-to-bottom audit of the Housing Authority.

The scandals also caused interim CEO Kenneth Simmons to resign his position with a request to return to his number two position with the authority.

On Tuesday, City Council members grilled the agency’s recently resigned interim CEO Ken Simmons about the audit’s findings.

Responding to an angry Councilman Bill Rosendahl, Simmons responded, “It wasn’t my initiative, sir. I don’t approve of it. I don’t agree with it.”

Simmons said the spending detailed in the audit did not include any federal funding that goes to subsidize rentals for residents or to build new housing. Instead the money came from close to 20 nonprofits that aid in the Housing Authority’s work.

Council members agreed the council should have more authority and oversight of the agency. Council members Jan Perry and Eric Garcetti introduced a motion asking the federal government to change regulations or pass necessary legislation to give the city direct authority over the Housing Authority.

Newly appointed commission chair Mitchell Kamin agreed the city should have more oversight of the agency and called for commissioners to be subject to investigation by the city Ethics Commission.

EGP News reports used in this story.

Print This Post Print This Post

December 15, 2011  Copyright © 2012 Eastern Group Publications, Inc.


Comments are intended to further discussion on the article topic. EGPNews reserves the right to not publish, edit or remove comments that contain vulgarities, foul language, personal attacks, racists, sexist, homophobic or other offensive terminology or that contain solicitations, spam, or that threaten harm of any sort. EGPNews will not approve comments that call for or applaud the death, injury or illness of any person, regardless of their public status. Questions regarding this policy should be e-mailed to service@egpnews.com.

 characters available

Copyright © 2018 Eastern Group Publications/EGPNews, Inc. ·